As Death Magnetic slowly begins, an interesting similarity arises between the introduction of “That Was Just Your Life” and that of Slayer’s “South of Heaven,” the first song from the second of the band’s albums produced by Rick Rubin. Both songs build slowly before commencing with an album’s worth of commercial thrash; a slower thrash in the case of South of Heaven and a seasoned thrash in the case of Death Magnetic. Additionally, both songs come from albums with which Rubin’s influence was clearly intact. He was there, helping elevate Slayer with Reign in Blood and twenty years after South of Heaven his imprint is evident as Metallica releases their ninth studio album; the band’s first under Warner’s imprint (though Warner now owns Elektra, Metallica’s prior label) and its first in seventeen years without producer and fill-in bassist Bob Rock.

Funny then that one of the main criticisms of Death Magnetic has been that it is self-plagiarizing, a term that could equally apply to a band like Slayer. It hasn’t though, primarily because Slayer has pretty much stuck with the same formula from the get-go; likewise, no one’s criticizing AC/DC for sounding too much like AC/DC with their new release, are they? So just what makes the criticism valid in Metallica’s case? For starters, the band’s return to speed comes after over a decade of “soul-searching” and “experimentation” (code: a string of easily dismissable albums spread out over far too many years). This might be why Pitchfork’s Cosmo Lee suggested that Death Magnetic is the musical equivalent of a mid-life crisis. It is after all an attempt by an aging band to return to their glory days by recapturing the sound and attitude that made them famous (exception: bassist Robert Trujillo who has continued to prove his diversity and prowess since first kicking it with Suicidal Tendencies back in the late-80’s). Even aesthetically the band has returned to its classic logo, one scarcely used since The Black Album. Fact is, Death Magnetic is an attempt at recreating Metallica – at that, the band has succeeded.

Rolling Stone’s Brian Hiatt attempted to define the vibrancy of the new sound in his recent review, “‘What don’t kill ya make ya more strong,’ Hetfield sings, with enough power to make the cliché feel fresh.” While partially true and a tad amusing, the description fails to capture the blinding truth that no matter what Metallica does at this point in time, it is going to be branded cliché. Had Metallica released another album’s worth of Load-sounding filler it would have been called cliché. Had the band gone further back into a grittier sound reflective of Kill ‘Em All it would have still been called cliché. At this point in time though it isn’t the music, but the band that is the cliché.

Even so, after St. Anger the odds of getting a solid album from Metallica were on level with the odds of drawing blood from a rock. But on the record James Hetfield sounds like the cocky frontman he was during the band’s heyday and both he and Kirk Hammett exchange solid riffs without a hint of “The Memory Remains” to be found. Maybe “The Unforgiven III” is a bit unnecessary, but at least it’s no “Unforgiven II.” And maybe the ten tracks on the album push the limits of human patience, all landing somewhere between five and ten minutes long, but they all ring true to what Metallica should be about. They’re loud, they’re heavy, they’re full of capable riffs and solos and for the most part they’re really good.

If the band had disappeared after 1993 only to reappear now with this release it would probably be openly received and accepted without the disdain that accompanies it given it’s history. Unfortunately we all know the details: Napster, Jason Newstead’s departure, rehab, psychiatry, etc. But to continue the comparison, Slayer fans want to hear Slayer when the band sounds like Slayer and Metallica fans love hearing the band when it sounds like Metallica. Death Magnetic sounds like Metallica; but it also sounds like it was written and recorded by a band of aging celebrities in its forties who are trying to relive their Scarface. But it also sounds better than most anyone expected it would and certainly far better than it should.

Official | MySpace | Wikipedia

Also: Metallica on Later with Jools Holland pt. 2 | Metallica on Later with Jools Holland